Skip to content
Peacock Search
ServicesLocationsIndustriesVisibility ReviewAI AutomationSearch NotesAboutWhatsAppBook review
Home / Search Notes / What Should Be Included in an SEO Audit?

Search Notes

What Should Be Included in an SEO Audit?

May 11, 2026

Supports The Visibility Review

A useful SEO audit explains what is holding performance back, why it matters, and what to fix first. A list of issues is not an audit.

Quick answer

A good audit covers six areas: crawlability and indexation, technical signals, site architecture and internal linking, content and search demand, on-page basics, and measurement. What makes it useful is the last layer: every finding is tied to a page or template, scored for impact, given an owner, and ordered into a plan.

The core areas

  • Crawlability and indexation: robots.txt, noindex, canonicals, sitemaps, and what Google has and has not indexed
  • Technical signals: status codes, redirects, rendering, structured data and page experience
  • Architecture and internal linking: how deep important pages sit, what links to them, and which pages are orphaned
  • Content and demand: which queries matter, which pages answer them, and where pages overlap or are thin
  • On-page basics: titles, descriptions, headings and how results look in search
  • Measurement: whether Search Console, analytics and conversion tracking can actually show what is working
  • Sector checks: local signals for local businesses, faceted navigation and category pages for ecommerce, archives for publishers

For how this differs from a technical-only review, see SEO audit vs technical SEO audit.

What a real audit output looks like

The format matters as much as the checks. The Visibility Review output follows the same structure each time. You can see an anonymised example on the sample outputs page.

It starts with a scorecard. Each area is scored from 1 to 5, and anything below 3 is picked up in the action plan. For an independent retailer with a Shopify store, the scorecard showed on-page content at 2 because collection pages were product grids with no supporting copy, and structured data at 2 because neither physical store had LocalBusiness markup.

Then the findings are split by priority:

  • Priority 1: issues actively blocking visibility or creating a trust risk, such as a placeholder phone number in the navigation that did not match the Google Business Profile
  • Priority 2: pages with organic potential that are underperforming, such as brand pages using the same supplier copy as every other stockist
  • Each finding states what is wrong, why it matters, the recommended fix, and who should do it

That last column is the difference between a report that gets used and one that sits in a folder. See how to turn an audit into an action plan.

Evidence matters more than volume

A strong finding shows a chain of evidence, not just a symptom. A page might rank poorly because the content is thin. But the real cause could be that the page is buried in the navigation, canonicalised to another URL, or competing with a near-duplicate.

For each finding, an audit should show:

  • The affected page or template
  • The evidence, from a crawl or Search Console
  • The likely cause
  • The recommended owner
  • The priority

Without that, a recommendation is an opinion.

What a good audit leaves out

A bloated audit is as unhelpful as a thin one. Leave out:

  • Tool health scores presented as findings
  • Hundreds of low-impact warnings, such as every missing image alt attribute, with no ranking
  • Generic advice that could apply to any site
  • Recommendations with no owner or effort estimate

Questions to ask before you commission one

  • Will it use Search Console data, or only a crawler export?
  • Will recommendations name pages and templates?
  • Will I get a prioritised plan, or a list?
  • Who is expected to implement it, and has their time been considered?
  • Is a review of the results included after the fixes go live?

Where the Visibility Review fits

The Visibility Review is built around this structure: scorecard, prioritised findings and a plan. The SEO audits page covers the offer, and the free audit template lets you run a first-look version yourself. If you only need a technical check, for example before a launch, see Technical SEO.

FAQ

How long should an SEO audit be?

Long enough to make the evidence and priorities clear, and no longer. A short action-led audit is usually more useful than a hundred-page export.

Does every site need a full audit?

No. A small site may only need a focused review. Large ecommerce, publishing and international sites usually need a deeper technical and content review.

What should I have ready for an audit?

Access to Search Console and analytics, a list of your most important pages, and a note of what the site is meant to achieve.

Related Search Notes

  • SEO Audit vs Technical SEO Audit
  • How to Turn an SEO Audit Into an Action Plan
  • Content Audit Framework: Keep, Improve, Consolidate or Remove

Practical use

How to turn this into action

  • Check whether the issue affects important templates, not just isolated URLs.
  • Separate urgent fixes from useful clean-up so the work can be prioritised.
  • Collect examples before briefing developers, writers or stakeholders.
  • Link the recommendation back to visibility, traffic quality or launch risk.
See how this supports The Visibility Review

Author

Written by Chris Payne

Chris Payne is the freelance SEO consultant behind Peacock Search. He has 8 years of SEO experience across ecommerce, publishing, UK and international websites, with a focus on technical SEO, content strategy, migrations and complex large-site audits.

More about Chris Payne
Peacock Search

Freelance SEO consultancy based in Romsey, specialising in audits, technical SEO, local SEO, content strategy and migration support.

Process SEO Audits Free SEO Audit Template Freelance SEO Consultant Agency Support AI Automation Sample Outputs Case Studies Privacy Cookies