Cannibalisation is not two pages sharing a keyword. It is two or more pages answering the same intent so that none of them is clearly the best answer.
Quick answer
Export Query by Page data from Search Console and look for queries where more than one URL gets impressions. Then ignore the noise: keep only queries with meaningful impressions, check whether the pages really serve the same intent, and look at whether Google keeps swapping which one it shows. If they do, either merge the pages or make their purposes clearly different.
How to find it in Search Console
- In Performance, set a date range of at least three months
- Add the Queries and Pages dimensions and export the Query by Page data
- Group by query and count how many different URLs appear for each
- Filter to queries with enough impressions to matter
- For each, note each URL's impressions and average position
Most overlap is harmless. The ones worth looking at are queries where several URLs share the impressions and none ranks well.
A real example from this site
When I ran this on peacocksearch.co.uk, 62 of 638 queries were served by more than one URL. Almost all the real overlap came from one group of pages: the Hampshire page, the Southampton page, the local SEO page and the locations hub.
For "seo services hampshire" (about 1,045 impressions), the Hampshire page got most of them, the local SEO page took some, and the hub appeared occasionally. All sat at position 90 or lower. For "seo consultant hampshire", the Hampshire page was around position 28, the Southampton page around 70, the Romsey page around 80, and the local SEO page appeared at position 12 on very few impressions.
Two points stand out. First, the competition was real, but it was a symptom. The pages had near-identical titles and headings, so Google had no clear reason to prefer one. Second, most of the pages were at positions where the difference hardly matters, so fixing cannibalisation alone would not get them to page one.
Confirm it is the same intent
Before changing anything, look at what each page is for.
- Same intent: both pages answer "freelance SEO consultant in Hampshire". Merge or differentiate.
- Different intent: one page explains a service, another is a guide on how to do it yourself. Leave them alone.
- Different location: "Southampton" and "Winchester" pages should serve their own town, not the county. If they rank for county terms, the town pages are not distinct enough.
You can check what Google prefers by searching the query and seeing which page types appear.
Decide what to do
- Merge when two pages are close duplicates and one is clearly weaker. Redirect the weaker one to the stronger.
- Differentiate when both have a reason to exist. Rewrite titles, H1s and opening copy so each targets a different query, and move overlapping content onto the page that should own it.
- Re-point internal links so the page you want to rank gets the links and anchor text for that term.
- Leave it when overlap is small, impressions are low, or intent differs.
Avoid using canonical tags to fix cannibalisation between genuinely different pages, and avoid noindex as a shortcut. Both hide the problem and can remove a page that deserved to exist.
What I changed
On this site I rewrote the titles and H1s of the Hampshire and Southampton pages so they target different queries, gave each town page its own focus, and retired 26 overlapping Search Notes, redirecting each to the page that replaced it. I will re-check Search Console in about four weeks before drawing any conclusion.
Track the result
After a change, record the date, the pages affected and the queries you expect to move. Check again after a few weeks. Rankings take time to settle, and changing the same pages again too soon makes the result impossible to read.
When to get support
Cannibalisation sits inside a wider content decision. The Content Strategy service and the Visibility Review both include a check for overlapping pages.
FAQ
Is keyword cannibalisation always bad?
No. It matters when pages compete for the same intent and neither is clearly the strongest.
How many pages ranking for a query is too many?
There is no fixed number. Look at whether the impressions are split in a way that keeps all of them low, and whether the pages really serve the same need.
Will merging pages improve rankings?
Often it helps, but it is not guaranteed. A merged page still has to be good enough to rank.